Audiobook Summary and Review by StoryShots
One consultant admitted it in three words: asked what he'd built, he said "guilty."
A firm that calls itself values-driven helped set off the pay gap that hollowed out the American middle class.
That is the thesis of When McKinsey Comes to Town, by Walt Bogdanich and Michael Forsythe, an investigation into the hidden influence of the world's most powerful consulting firm.
McKinsey sells itself as a scientific problem solver, brought in to find objective truth.
Most people assume a consultant's job is to tell clients what they need to hear, not what they want to hear.
That is not how it works.
Consultants are frequently hired to justify a decision the chief executive already wants to make, then absorb none of the blame when it goes wrong.
At U.S. Steel in Gary, Indiana, McKinsey promised a turnaround built on economic profit and innovation.
Workers ended up fighting cost cuts they said put their lives at risk.
Two men were electrocuted outside a plant gate not long after.
The company never signs the layoff notice.
It only writes the memo that makes the layoff look inevitable.
McKinsey's fingerprints rarely show up in a press release, and that design flaw becomes even clearer once you see how one internal study reshaped executive pay for good.
In 1950, a McKinsey partner named Arch Patton ran a study that would quietly reshape American capitalism.
He compared executive salaries across companies and handed board members a new argument for paying their bosses more.
Back then, the typical executive earned about twenty times what a production worker made.
That ratio has since climbed past three hundred and fifty times.
Patton's research did not just inform boardrooms, it gave them a benchmark, and once one company raised executive pay, competitors felt pressure to match it.
A single slide deck from 1950 helped launch an arms race in executive compensation that still has not stopped.
That fact alone says something unsettling about how easily economic norms get engineered by people nobody ever elected.
Every time your raise fails to keep pace with your CEO's bonus, part of the explanation traces back to a study most workers have never heard of.
There is no shadowy council secretly running the planet.
There does not need to be, because McKinsey already advises the CIA, the FBI, the Pentagon, Purdue Pharma, Saudi Aramco, and the Chinese government, often at the same time, often on opposite sides of the same conflict.
McKinsey has profited from advising both the regulators and the industries those regulators are supposed to police.
Decisions affecting your job, your healthcare, or your government are often made somewhere far above your reach, and the firm that helped shape that call answers to almost no one.
If this made you rethink who actually shapes the decisions in your life, send this summary to someone who works in business, policy, or government.
This summary of When McKinsey Comes to Town connects three threads: consultants who take no responsibility for outcomes, a 1950 study that helped supercharge executive pay, and a firm so embedded in both corporations and governments that conflicts of interest become routine.
Walt Bogdanich and Michael Forsythe uncover far more in the full book, including McKinsey's role in turbocharging opioid sales for Purdue Pharma, its work advising ICE and authoritarian governments from Riyadh to Beijing, and the internal up or out culture that keeps young consultants chasing client growth over conscience.
Anyone in business, policy, or corporate leadership should sit with what this book uncovers.
We're putting together the full summary of When McKinsey Comes to Town right now, complete with an infographic and animated video.
Follow the book in the StoryShots app to get it the moment it's ready.